Home › How to Play › Catan › Rules reference
CITIES & KNIGHTS · PROGRESS CARD RULES

Catan Cities & Knights Progress Cards: Hand Limit and Timing

How to gain green, blue and yellow Progress cards, handle the fifth card, and know when a special card may be played.

DRAW · HOLD · DISCARD
SOURCE-CHECKED REFERENCECatan: Cities & Knights

Official rulebook and real examples

RulesTimingFAQ

Quick answer: how many progress cards may you hold?

In Catan: Cities & Knights, you normally may hold no more than four Progress cards. The expansion replaces the base game’s Development cards with yellow Trade, blue Politics and green Science Progress decks.

If you receive a fifth Progress card during another player’s turn, look at it and immediately choose one card to return face down to the bottom of its matching Progress deck. If you receive the fifth on your own turn, you may play eligible cards first, but you must return to four or fewer before ending the turn.

Victory Point Progress cards are handled as a special exception and are not counted like ordinary cards in the four-card limit. The official 2025 rulebook and CATAN FAQ should take priority over an older quick-reference sheet.

How are green, blue and yellow cards earned?

Each Progress deck corresponds to a city-improvement track: Science is green, Politics is blue and Trade is yellow. Improving a city track allows you to qualify for Progress cards when the event die shows its corresponding city gate and the red die is within the track’s eligible numbers.

The card is not bought like a base-game Development card. Check the event die, red die and your city-improvement level after the roll, according to the printed chart. If qualified, draw the top card of the indicated color.

For example, you have developed the Science track enough to qualify for certain red-die results. A green city gate on the event die plus a qualifying red result earns a green card. Merely seeing green on the event die is not sufficient if your improvement level does not qualify.

When in the turn does the Progress draw happen?

The Progress card entitlement is determined from the production dice and event die. If several players qualify, follow the prescribed draw order and resolve card-limit decisions as required before continuing with later turn actions.

A key off-turn edge case is drawing a fifth Progress card. The official CATAN FAQ says the extra-card discard occurs immediately, before the dice result finishes resolving production of resources and commodities.

On your own turn, you may temporarily exceed the four-card cap because you have opportunities to play a Progress card before your turn ends. The temporary exception is not permission to keep five cards into the next player’s turn.

How to discard a fifth card legally

When a fifth ordinary Progress card arrives off-turn, look at the newly drawn card and your existing cards, then choose any one to return. The rule does not force you to discard the one you just drew.

Return the discarded card face down to the bottom of its matching colored deck. The Progress decks recycle cards underneath; unlike a normal deck-building discard pile, there is no separate Progress-card discard pile to reshuffle.

Worked example: you hold two blue, one green and one yellow Progress card. On an opponent’s turn you qualify for another green card. You may keep the new green and return the old yellow to the yellow deck, leaving four cards total.

Victory Point progress cards and the hand limit

Some Progress cards award Victory Points. The official rules distinguish these from ordinary Progress cards, and they do not count toward the normal four-card hand limit when kept under their printed special procedure.

This matters when a card limit is checked during the event-die resolution. Do not force a player to discard a qualifying VP card merely because their ordinary Progress-card hand contains four.

If a Victory Point Progress card has specific face-up, play or award instructions, follow those instructions. The separate Defender of Catan reward from a barbarian victory is not simply an ordinary Progress card in hand.

Can you play progress cards whenever you wish?

Progress cards are generally played during your own turn, following their card text and the timing rules for that color. Unlike base-game Development cards, you may be able to play multiple Progress cards during one turn when their effects are independently legal.

You may not normally play cards from your Progress hand before rolling the dice. The rulebook and official FAQ identify Alchemist as the specific before-roll exception: it changes the dice results as its card directs.

A Progress card may also specify a narrower timing window or precondition. Always apply the card’s actual text rather than treating every yellow, blue or green card as a freely usable instant effect on someone else’s turn.

Alchemist: the before-roll exception

Alchemist is the well-known exception: it can be played before your roll and lets you choose the numbers showing on the two production dice within its rules, rather than randomly rolling those two dice as usual.

It does not let you ignore the event die or avoid every other part of the ordinary roll procedure. Resolve the event die and the outcomes using the card’s printed instructions.

Example: you have Alchemist in hand and want a particular production total. You may play it at the authorized pre-roll moment. Playing a non-Alchemist Progress card at the same moment is not permitted solely because its effect might be useful before production.

May you play a card that does nothing?

The official FAQ distinguishes known lack of effect from a card with an uncertain outcome. If you already know a Progress card will have no effect, you generally cannot play it merely to free hand space.

For example, playing Mining while you have no settlement or city adjacent to mountains is not legal just to discard a Progress card and avoid the hand limit. By contrast, a card such as a Monopoly may have a legal effect whose outcome is unknown.

If you cannot legally play an excess card on your own turn, return a card to its appropriate deck at the mandatory hand-limit point. The hand limit is not an authorization to invent a no-op card play.

Can you trade Progress cards with another player?

No. Progress cards are not among the resource and commodity cards available for ordinary player trading. You cannot offer a blue Politics card in exchange for grain, even when the other player needs its ability.

The ability to trade commodities is distinct from trading Progress cards. Cities & Knights uses paper, cloth and coin commodities to buy improvements, while the earned Progress cards themselves follow the dedicated draw and play rules.

Keep the Progress-card hand separate from your ordinary resource and commodity hand. The robber’s resource-card discard check and the Progress-card limit are governed by different counting rules.

Are Progress cards included when a seven is rolled?

When a seven causes players to discard resource cards for having too many cards, resources and commodities count under the Catan hand-size rule, while the Progress-card hand is not simply added to the same total.

For example, if you hold four Progress cards and six resource/commodity cards, do not count ten and automatically discard for the robber’s hand-size threshold. Instead apply the rules to the resource and commodity cards that actually count.

Progress cards have their own separate four-card cap. The difference is important after a favorable event-die result, when a player can be managing Progress-card space and production from the same dice roll.

Where do played and discarded Progress cards go?

After use, return Progress cards face down under their respective colored Progress decks. Yellow cards return to the yellow deck, blue to blue and green to green.

The CATAN FAQ says you never reshuffle a separate Progress discard pile, because there is no normal discard pile of that type. Putting played cards underneath maintains the replenishing Progress-card cycle.

If the available deck is briefly exhausted while more than one player is entitled to draw, follow the printed draw order; do not take an unavailable card from another color to compensate.

Worked example: fifth card on your turn and off your turn

During your own turn you hold four ordinary Progress cards and gain a fifth after the event-die result. You may play a legal Progress card later during that same turn, returning to four. If no qualifying play occurs, return one ordinary card face down to its deck before ending the turn.

Later, another player rolls and the event die qualifies you for a fifth card again. Now you must choose a Progress card to return immediately, before resource/commodity production from that roll is fully resolved.

In neither case do you automatically lose the newly drawn card. You may review your hand and choose the least useful legal discard; the difference is how long you may keep five depending on whose turn it is.

Mistakes that cause card-timing disputes

Confusing the four-card limit with seven-resource discards. Progress and resource/commodity cards are counted under different rules.

Allowing off-turn players to wait. Their fifth ordinary Progress card requires an immediate discard choice, not a decision after production is complete.

Playing an empty-effect Progress card. You cannot normally discard a card by pretending to use an effect you know cannot occur.

Using ordinary Development-card restrictions. The Cities & Knights Progress system replaces the base game Development cards and has its own play timing.

Cities & Knights Progress-card FAQ

How many ordinary Progress cards may I hold? Four.

Can I inspect a fifth card before discarding? Yes.

When is an off-turn fifth card discarded? Immediately.

Can a fifth card remain temporarily on my turn? Yes, but resolve the limit by turn end.

Can I play any Progress card before rolling? No, only Alchemist under its exception.

Can I trade Progress cards? No.

Do VP Progress cards count against four? No, under their special rule.

Do played cards enter a discard pile? No, return them under the appropriate colored deck.

Publisher rules, versions and related guides

Rules checked against the publisher’s official Cities & Knights FAQ and CATAN’s 2025 rulebook download directory. The FAQ confirms fifth-card timing, Alchemist before dice, the special Victory Point cards and returning cards under their decks.

Learn at Your LevelFrom beginner to expert
Complete CoverageRules, strategy, expansions and more
Trusted RecommendationsCurated by board game enthusiasts
Always UpdatedNew guides and games regularly

Similar Posts