Home › How to Play › Catan › Barbarian attacks
CITIES & KNIGHTS · EVERGREEN RULES

Catan Cities & Knights: Barbarian Attacks and Active Knight Rules

Defense strength, rewards, metropolis exceptions and worked examples for the barbarian attack.

BARBARIANS • ACTIVE KNIGHTS • CITY LOSS
DEFEND CATANCount active knights—not inactive pieces

Strength, tie handling and city loss explained

1 / 2 / 3 strengthDefense ties win

Quick answer: barbarian attacks in Cities & Knights

In Catan: Cities & Knights, the barbarian ship advances toward Catan. When it reaches the final space, count one barbarian strength for each city on the island, including metropolises. Add up the strengths of all active knights belonging to all players. A combined defense equal to or greater than the barbarians’ strength succeeds.

If the defense succeeds, the strongest individual defender may receive a reward. If it fails, the player or players with the weakest eligible contributions lose an ordinary city, reducing it to a settlement. Importantly, several players can be tied for weakest, so city losses are not always limited to one player.

This is the Cities & Knights system of physical knights on the map, not the original Catan Knight development-card effect. For a full expansion introduction, read How to Play Cities & Knights.

When does the barbarian ship attack?

The event die can show a barbarian ship icon. When it does, advance the barbarian ship one space along its track. When the ship arrives at Catan, resolve an attack immediately according to the expansion’s turn sequence. Do not wait until the next player has finished their ordinary turn.

After resolving the result, return the ship to the beginning of the track. The countdown then begins again. Because the event die is random, a series of ship results can bring an attack sooner than expected, making inactive knights a risk.

The first attack is especially important because players begin with cities, which already contribute to barbarian strength. A city is valuable for producing commodities, but adding cities without defense also raises the difficulty of protecting the whole island.

How to calculate attacker strength

Barbarian strength equals the total number of ordinary cities plus metropolises on the game board. Settlements do not contribute. The count is made when the invasion happens, so it can grow or shrink throughout a session.

Example: there are four ordinary cities and one metropolis. Attacker strength is five. If another player upgrades a settlement to a city before the ship arrives, the attackers become strength six.

An individual player cannot opt out of this shared count. The barbarians attack Catan as a whole, so one player’s ambitious city development can make the defense harder for everyone, even someone with no cities of their own.

Active versus inactive knights

A basic knight supplies one strength, a strong knight two, and a mighty knight three, but only while active. An inactive mighty knight contributes zero to this attack, no matter how expensive it was to promote.

Activation costs one grain, regardless of knight rank. The printed knight piece or marker indicates whether the knight is active. Players can recruit, activate and promote knights according to the normal actions and their permitted timing.

A knight used for another knight action may be deactivated, so it might no longer contribute if the ship arrives later. Use the current state of every knight, not its strength on a previous turn. The official Cities & Knights FAQ addresses this distinction.

Defender strength: everyone adds together

The defending army is the sum of every player’s active knight strength. This is a cooperative total, even though players compete for victory points and trading advantages. You do not compare each player’s army separately against the full barbarian army.

Suppose A has an active strong knight (two), B has three active basic knights (three), and C has no active knights. Their total defense is five. If Catan has five cities, defense succeeds on the tie. If it has six cities, the same army is one point too weak.

A knight belonging to a player without any city can still support collective defense. Having no city changes the player’s potential city loss, not the rule that their active knights participate in the common defense.

Who gets Defender of Catan when defense succeeds?

After a successful defense, compare each player’s individual strength contribution. If exactly one player supplied the most active strength, that player receives the Defender of Catan victory-point reward under the normal rules.

If two or more players tie for the largest contribution, no unique defender victory-point reward is awarded. Instead, those tied leading players receive the appropriate progress-card rewards, choosing from eligible decks as the published rules specify.

Example: defense totals six against five attackers. Contributions are three, three and zero. The two players with three are tied for largest, so neither is singled out for the defender VP. This is different from a tie between the combined defending army and the barbarian strength, which is itself a successful defense.

When barbarians win: who loses a city?

If attacker strength exceeds the defenders’ total, the barbarians win. Compare the individual active knight strengths of players eligible to lose an ordinary city. The weakest eligible player loses one city, downgraded to a settlement.

If several players are tied for weakest and each is eligible, each of them may lose one ordinary city. An owner with no city cannot lose one. The official rules also protect owners whose only cities are metropolises.

For example, if contributions are A two, B one, C one, D zero, but D has only settlements, D is not a candidate for city loss. Among eligible city owners, B and C may now be tied at one and both face a downgrade. Do not automatically punish D for having contributed zero.

Can barbarians pillage a metropolis?

A metropolis counts when establishing barbarian strength, but cannot be reduced by the normal barbarian pillaging mechanism. A player with only metropolises and no vulnerable ordinary city is therefore immune to the city-loss step.

This does not mean that holding a metropolis grants blanket immunity to all of your buildings. If you have a metropolis and an ordinary city, the ordinary city can still be the target if you are the weakest eligible contributor.

The distinction matters when calculating both sides of the invasion: metropolises increase how strong the barbarians are, while their protected status can change which players are eligible for losses. Verify the actual board state at the moment of the attack.

What happens to knights and the ship after a battle?

After resolving an attack under the standard rules, all active knights deactivate, whether the defenders won or lost. Reset the ship’s position to begin the next approach. Players must spend further grain to reactivate knights if they want their strength to count next time.

If a city was downgraded, recalculate barbarian strength for future attacks: there may now be one fewer city contributing to the next invasion. A weak defense can therefore change the shared military difficulty as well as the owners’ production.

Do not leave knights showing active simply because their faction contributed to a successful defense. The publisher’s FAQ explicitly notes that active knights participate in the battle and are then deactivated.

Knight actions can leave the defense exposed

An active knight may perform certain actions, such as moving or displacing an opponent’s knight when the necessary conditions are met. Using the knight this way can require deactivation, reducing the available defenders until it is activated again.

If the barbarian ship is only one step from Catan, evaluate the cost of an aggressive knight move against the possibility of the next event roll causing an invasion. Choosing a short-term position advantage can create a shared defense shortfall.

The same tension influences promotions: a stronger knight offers more strength per piece, but the correct activation status is still required. Having a mighty knight piece on the board cannot rescue a losing defense if it remains inactive.

Full worked example: five cities, four knight strength

There are five cities across the island, including one metropolis. Player A has two active basic knights (strength two), B has one active strong knight (two), and C has no active knights. Combined defense is four, and the barbarians attack at five.

Because four is less than five, the barbarians win. If C owns an ordinary city, C is the unique weakest eligible defender (zero) and downgrades one ordinary city. A and B retain their cities. If C has no ordinary city, determine the weakest among those who can actually lose one.

The attack then ends. The surviving active knights of A and B become inactive, the ship resets, and the group assesses the city count for the next attack. A failure should not be treated as permanently eliminating any player’s knights.

Mistakes that regularly cause disputes

Mistake one: adding inactive knights to defense. Their rank and physical presence are irrelevant unless active at the attack.

Mistake two: comparing individual players directly against barbarian strength. Everyone’s active knight strength is combined first; contributions matter again only for rewards or losses.

Mistake three: awarding a Defender VP to one of two tied top defenders, or ignoring the progress-card alternative. The rule treats a unique largest contributor differently from a tie.

Mistake four: losing a metropolis, penalizing a player with no eligible city, or forgetting to deactivate surviving knights after the battle.

Barbarian attack rules FAQ

How strong are the barbarians? One strength per city, including metropolises.

Do inactive knights contribute? No.

Does defense win on a tie? Yes.

Can two players both lose a city? Yes, if they tie as weakest eligible defenders.

Do metropolises increase barbarian strength? Yes, even though they are protected from normal barbarian pillaging.

What if two defenders tie for strongest? No unique Defender VP; tied leaders receive the specified progress cards.

Are knights reset after an attack? They deactivate; the barbarian ship resets.

Are Catan’s normal Knight development cards involved? No. This expansion uses its own active knight pieces.

Publisher sources, editions and nearby guides

Checked November 19, 2026 using the official Cities & Knights FAQ, publisher expansion overview and Catan rulebook download directory. The publisher’s scenario or edition-specific instructions take priority in edge cases.

Learn at Your LevelFrom beginner to expert
Complete CoverageRules, strategy, expansions and more
Trusted RecommendationsCurated by board game enthusiasts
Always UpdatedNew guides and games regularly

Similar Posts