How to Play Apples to Apples: Judge, Cards & Scoring
Learn the five-card starting hand, Green Apple judge, face-down Red Apple submissions, winner selection, four-card win target and official variations.
Edition-specific instructions and original worked examples
Quick answer: how do you play Apples to Apples?
In Apples to Apples, players try to persuade a rotating judge that a card in their hand is the funniest, most fitting or most interesting response to a descriptive word. The judge reads a word from a Green Apple card, and everybody else submits a Red Apple card face down.
The judge mixes and reveals the submissions, picks a favorite and awards the Green Apple card to the player who submitted it. In Mattel’s BGG15 Party Box instructions, the first person to collect four Green Apple cards wins.
This guide deliberately uses the BGG15 4–8-player rule sheet. The current CJB31 online listing and older family or larger Party Box editions differ in inventories, so do not assume that every box has the same number of cards or victory target.
Step 1: identify the two card decks
The game has Red Apple cards, each naming a person, place, thing or situation, and Green Apple cards, each offering descriptive words that the judge will compare the submissions against.
In the BGG15 package, Mattel lists 438 printed Red Apple cards, 62 printed Green Apple cards, three blank red cards and one blank green card. Together these make 504 physical cards. The blanks let the group personalize the set if desired.
Those numbers describe the BGG15 printing only. Another Mattel listing for product CJB31 uses different printed-versus-blank component labels, so check your own box before claiming missing cards.
Step 2: shuffle red and green cards separately
Shuffle the Red Apple cards into one collection and Green Apple cards into another; do not combine them into a single deck.
Mattel’s Party Box has separate storage wells for the red cards and one well for the green. For the round, put a portion of the red deck and the green deck face down within easy reach.
Leave enough table space for a group of face-down submitted red cards and a discard area. The judge needs to be able to mix the submitted cards without seeing who played each one.
Step 3: choose the first judge and deal five reds
Choose a starting judge by agreement. This player manages the current Green Apple prompt and determines which submission wins the round.
The judge deals five Red Apple cards face down to each player, including the judge. Everyone may look at their own cards but should keep the contents private from the other participants.
Although the judge holds five red cards, they do not submit a Red Apple card during their own judging round. Their job is to select the winner among the other players’ submissions.
Step 4: the judge announces a green description
The judge takes one Green Apple card and chooses one of its descriptive words to use for the round. They read that chosen word aloud and put the green card face up where everyone can see it.
In Mattel’s BGG15 rulebook, a green card presents two descriptive choices, so the judge has a choice of prompt; the round is not automatically about using both descriptions.
The players should know which specific description is being judged before selecting their red response. A difficult or humorous description is part of the experience, not a signal that only literal matches can win.
Step 5: every non-judge player submits a red card
Each participant except the judge chooses one Red Apple card from their own five-card hand that they believe fits the active green description well.
Put the chosen red card face down into the center. Do not show it to the judge, and do not deliberately mark the back to reveal who chose it. Keeping the authors hidden helps the judge react to the comparison rather than the player’s identity.
A player may deliberately submit an unexpected joke or association. The standard game does not require that every card be the most literal dictionary match.
Optional Quick Pick: the last card can be excluded
Mattel’s BGG15 booklet includes a Quick Pick option for games with five or more participants. Under this option, the last person to submit a Red Apple card is not included in judging that round.
The last card is simply returned to that player’s hand; it is not played as a losing answer. This option changes the timing pressure, so tell everyone before the round starts whether it is active.
For a relaxed family game, omit Quick Pick entirely. The main rules permit people to make a considered submission without a separate speed penalty.
Step 6: mix the submissions and reveal them
Once the eligible submissions are collected, the judge mixes the face-down red cards so their owners are not obvious, then turns them over one by one and reads them aloud.
Do not ask every participant to announce the name of their own chosen card before mixing; that would defeat the intended anonymity of the initial selection.
Some choices may sound very plausible and others ridiculous. Both can be legitimate submissions because the judge chooses a favorite rather than checking one predetermined answer.
Step 7: discuss why the cards fit
The BGG15 rules explicitly encourage table talk. After the red cards are revealed, players can explain why a surprising comparison actually makes sense or why it is especially amusing.
For example, imagine the green description is ‘mysterious’. One player might choose a generic example such as ‘an old library,’ while another offers ‘a locked suitcase.’ The discussion turns on which seems more intriguing to the judge.
These hypothetical examples are original teaching prompts, not quotations from Mattel’s licensed red or green deck. Participants should keep the exchange respectful and let the judge decide.
Step 8: the judge picks a favorite
After considering the revealed red submissions and any explanations, the judge chooses one favorite Red Apple card. It can be the funniest, most apt or most unexpected option according to that judge’s taste.
The player who supplied that Red Apple card is the winner of the round. Award them the Green Apple prompt card as their scoring token.
Do not give a second green point merely because another answer was also good. The ordinary round has one winner, and the judge’s subjective judgment is part of the game.
Step 9: discard submissions and rotate the judge
Put the submitted red cards into a discard pile. Hand the judging role and access to the decks to the player on the left.
The new judge deals enough Red Apple cards for each participant to return to five cards in hand. Because the previous judge did not submit, they may already have five and need no new card.
The new judge reads a fresh Green Apple prompt and another round begins. This rotation gives every player a chance to select the comparisons instead of relying on one permanent arbiter.
How to win in Mattel BGG15
The first player to collect four Green Apple cards wins under the official BGG15 rule sheet. Keep won green cards in front of each person so the score is visible.
Do not give victory to the person who submitted the most red cards or the person whose answer sounded most logical. The winning resource is the number of green judging cards awarded.
A different Apples to Apples edition may prescribe a variable target based on the player count. This page does not claim that the BGG15 four-card target is a universal rule for every printing.
Worked example: a complete judging round
Five people are playing. One is the judge, and the other four secretly choose a red card responding to the active green description. Suppose the chosen description is ‘unexpected’.
The judge mixes the four submissions and reads them without knowing who placed each one. The players offer brief explanations; the judge picks the comparison they find most surprising.
That player receives one Green Apple card. All four submitted red cards are discarded, the judge passes left, and the next judge tops everybody’s hand back up to five before starting the following round.
Official variant: Crab Apples
The BGG15 booklet names Crab Apples, a variation where players aim for a card that is least like—or the opposite of—the green description rather than the closest match.
The judge still chooses the winning comparison, but it is a contest of creatively inappropriate or contrasting answers. The rest of the submission, scoring and judge-rotation structure remains recognizable.
Announce Crab Apples before the round. Mixing ‘best fit’ and ‘worst fit’ objectives without warning makes the judge’s choice impossible to evaluate fairly.
Official variant: 2 for 1 Apples
In 2 for 1 Apples, each player chooses a Red Apple response that fits both descriptive words on the current Green Apple card.
That is harder than the standard game, where the judge selects one of the two words. A red answer may fit one word perfectly yet seem completely unrelated to the other.
The judge evaluates the combined comparison and awards the Green Apple accordingly. Agree to use this mode before players submit their cards.
Playing with fewer than four people
The cited BGG15 edition recommends four to eight players. With fewer than four, the standard one-judge-and-other-players dynamic has fewer answers and much less of the social debate that drives the game.
Some older manuals describe special three-player procedures, but those belong to a different rulebook and should not be imported into the BGG15 format without explicitly identifying the variation.
For a group of three, you can choose an informal adaptation, but the page does not present it as the official BGG15 main game.
Common Apples to Apples rules mistakes
Do not have the judge submit their own Red Apple during their judging round. Do not mix red and green decks, or award the red submission itself as the score instead of the Green Apple prompt.
Do not assume the first red answer placed wins. Unless the optional Quick Pick rule is active, the judge considers the submissions after they are mixed and revealed.
Do not force a rigid objective answer, because the judge’s preference is the intended mechanism. Finally, avoid mixing component counts or green-card win targets from separate printings.
Apples to Apples rules FAQ
How many red cards start in a hand? Five in BGG15. Does the judge play a red answer? No. Can players defend a funny answer? Yes; the official rules encourage discussion.
Who receives the Green Apple? The player whose red answer wins the judging round. How many Green Apples win? Four under BGG15. What is Quick Pick? An optional speed rule for five or more players.
Are all Mattel Apples to Apples boxes identical? No. The number of cards and detailed scoring can vary by printing or variant.
Primary Mattel manual and separate game overview
This rules guide is tied specifically to Mattel’s official Apples to Apples BGG15 instruction sheet (English PDF). For comparison, Mattel’s CJB31 product page describes a current standard retail printing with differently presented inventory information.
The wording, examples and explanations here are original. No copyrighted card faces are reproduced. Read the separate Apples to Apples overview for edition guidance, suitability and comparisons with other party games.