CATAN: Cities & Knights Strategy Guide
Prepare for the first barbarian invasion, develop productive cities, win metropolises and convert improvements into thirteen victory points.
Commodity engine · Metropolis race · 13 VP
Cities & Knights strategy: defend before you accelerate
CATAN: Cities & Knights creates two competing clocks: the shared barbarian ship is moving toward an attack, while each player is racing to improve cities and score 13 victory points. Successful play requires progress in both. If you ignore knights and lose an early city, you may also lose the ability to buy further city improvements until you rebuild.
The best opening is not a universal diagram showing the same three intersections every time. Initial hex numbers, starting city production, trade positions and opponents’ plans change the economy. But the broad priorities are dependable: secure grain and a working knight, produce commodities, then convert development into progress cards and points.
Because this expansion increases the victory target from ten to thirteen, a familiar base-game strategy of sprinting toward a few early settlements may not be enough. Metropolises provide two extra points each and are contested by improvement-track level.
We use the official 2025 game structure and publisher FAQ rather than hypothetical card powers. These recommendations are strategic reasoning, not measured win rates or a promise that every opening follows the same path. For an exact turn tutorial first, read our Cities & Knights rules guide.
Choosing the initial settlement and city
In Cities & Knights, you begin with one settlement and one city. That makes the city’s placement unusually important: a city produces commodities from forest, pasture and mountain hexes, while the settlement produces only normal resources.
A city touching favorable numbers on forest and mountain can offer paper and coin for science and politics, while an adjacent pasture provides cloth for trade. A balance of one or two commodity types plus useful ordinary resources is often better than a city that produces only grain-heavy combinations.
Do not ignore grain. It is needed to activate knights, and its supply matters again after each barbarian attack deactivates your force. An excellent commodity engine with no reliable activation fuel can become vulnerable at precisely the wrong time.
Road access remains relevant. Knights must occupy legal road-connected intersections and can block or defend routes. A city hemmed in by opponents may produce well but restrict your ability to expand into promising settlement locations later.
Consider the opponents’ positions too. If another player controls the only strong mountain production, the politics metropolis might become expensive to contest. A strong early city still needs a realistic path to the points you plan to claim.
Surviving the first barbarian attack
CATAN says the event die has three barbarian-ship faces, so the ship advances on roughly half of all rolls. Depending on the sequence, the first invasion can occur surprisingly early. Do not plan as though you have plenty of turns to assemble your army.
A basic knight costs one wool and one ore. Activating it costs one grain. If you can afford that three-resource investment soon after setup, you become less exposed than a player who has no activated knights at all.
Importantly, you can recruit and activate a knight on the same turn, but you cannot activate it and then take a knight action. Defence against barbarians relies on the knight staying active until the attack, not on moving it in the final moment.
Review the ship’s location at every event die result. If it is nearly at the coast, converting your last grain into a city or road may be a mistake. An inactive knight contributes zero strength even if it is the strongest piece on the table.
The group only needs active knights equal to the army’s strength to defend successfully. But a collective victory may reward the player who contributed the most, so having one more strength point than the others can be a scoring opportunity rather than wasteful overinvestment.
Why grain is more important than it first appears
In ordinary CATAN, grain is valuable for settlements, cities and development-card purchases. Cities & Knights adds another recurring role: every knight activation costs one grain, whether the knight is basic or mighty.
After a barbarian attack, the standard rules deactivate active knights. A player with several strong pieces may suddenly need multiple grain cards before those pieces are useful again. That is why a high-quality grain hex or favorable grain trade route can carry value for the full game.
A shortage of grain can make an expensive mighty knight effectively useless. It might look impressive on the board, but its printed strength does not count against barbarians while the piece is inactive.
On the other hand, excessive grain can be a weakness if you lack wool and ore to recruit additional knights. The best opening is a balanced production mix, plus trades or progress-card effects to cover gaps.
When evaluating a proposed trade, ask whether it uses grain you need before the next likely attack. An attractive paper or cloth purchase can become costly if you must then trade two or three cards to activate your defence force.
Commodity production and city improvement tracks
The three commodity types—paper, cloth and coin—fuel science, trade and politics improvements. These tracks are not interchangeable. A surplus of paper advances science, while a coin-producing city naturally points toward politics.
Building a city beside forests, pastures or mountains gives one normal resource plus one matching commodity instead of two ordinary resources on those terrain types. This can create a powerful engine for repeated improvement purchases.
Choose the first improvement track that actually fits your production rather than declaring at setup that green is always best. If you generate more coins than paper, a politics strategy may mature much earlier than a science plan that requires unfavorable trades.
However, improvement levels also influence progress-card draws. A track that reaches level two or three early can generate extra opportunities across many future turns, so an improvement with no immediate victory point may still be a strong investment.
The danger is spreading commodities too widely. Reaching level two in all three tracks may feel balanced, but another player who specializes could claim a level-four metropolis first. Compare your likely remaining production against their improvement totals before committing resources.
When to prioritize science and the Aqueduct
The third science improvement grants an Aqueduct-style resource safety net: when a normal production roll gives you no cards, you may collect one resource of your choice, except on a seven. This is valuable on boards where your numbers are uneven.
Its benefit is not merely the direct card. A resource you can choose may cover the exact missing grain, ore, wool or brick needed to activate a knight, build a city wall or finish an expansion route.
Science can therefore be a strong early track for players whose city produces paper reliably and who expect many future production rolls. The earlier you reach the level-three ability, the more chances it has to smooth out unlucky turns.
But a science-first plan can lose value when your paper production is poor or another player races ahead in the same color. You still need to defend, and a green progress card does not stop the barbarians unless its printed effect actually contributes.
Watch the level-four and level-five thresholds. If a rival is one paper purchase away from permanently securing the science metropolis, you may need to switch your scoring plan rather than chase a nearly lost race.
When to prioritize trade and the 2:1 commodity exchange
At the third trade improvement, you gain the ability to exchange two identical commodities for one resource or commodity. This helps an economic engine turn repeated cloth production into whichever material the next purchase requires.
The value rises with surplus commodities. A city producing cloth on a frequent number can create a repeatable way to obtain paper, coin, ore or grain. That flexibility can be especially useful when port access is limited.
Do not confuse this improvement with a universal two-for-one trade for any two ordinary resources. The publisher specifies that the required cards are identical commodities; ordinary grain and brick do not suddenly become eligible for this ability.
Trade is often strongest if you have several settlements or cities producing useful materials but have mismatched costs. It can also help finance level-four or level-five metropolis improvements when you lack direct production of the appropriate commodity.
The opportunity cost matters: if spending two commodities repeatedly would prevent you from improving your own track, you may be converting away your progress instead of accelerating it. Compare the new card’s purpose with the improvement you could have purchased later.
When to prioritize politics and mighty knights
The third politics improvement allows you to promote strong knights to mighty knights. Mighty knights have strength three, giving more defence per active piece and increasing the threat you can pose to opponents’ road-connected knights.
Because both recruitment and promotion use wool and ore, a strong ore engine can help this strategy. Yet you still need grain to activate the larger knight; promotion does not automatically switch an inactive piece on.
A mighty knight can influence the board beyond barbarian combat. An active knight can protect routes, displace weaker enemy knights under the rules and chase away the robber from adjacent hexes. These effects can matter in a closely contested game.
Politics improvements also lead to progress-card opportunities, some of which can disrupt rival plans. This can be effective when opponents have invested heavily in long roads or expensive city locations that depend on a particular shared area.
Do not build every mighty knight simply because you can. A knight occupies an intersection and must be legally road-connected. If its position does not help you defend or interact, the promotion resources might produce more value as another city improvement or scoring action.
Winning the metropolis race without wasting commodities
There are three metropolises, worth two additional victory points each. The first player to reach level four in a given improvement track claims that metropolis, but a rival reaching level five first can take it away.
The important strategic distinction is between temporary level-four control and permanent level-five control. Spending resources to claim a metropolis at level four can be useful for an early point lead, but the position is exposed until someone reaches the fifth improvement.
Before buying a fourth-level improvement, look at the other players’ markers and commodity production. If someone else can easily buy the fifth level on their next turn, your two-point gain may be short-lived.
Conversely, taking the fifth improvement first can deny an opponent two points and secure your own two—a four-point relative swing in a two-player comparison of those scores. That makes timing an important part of a thirteen-point race.
Keep physical city space available: each metropolis needs its own city. One city cannot support two separate metropolis pieces. A player specializing in multiple tracks may need another settlement upgraded to a city before claiming a second reward.
Use progress cards as timely actions, not trophies
In Cities & Knights, progress cards are drawn when the event die color and red die qualify against your improvement track. You do not simply buy them with the base-game development-card formula.
The science deck generally supports production and construction, trade modifies exchanges, and politics provides disruptive or knight-related effects. The exact value depends on your board state; there is no credible universal ranking of every card independent of its conditions.
For example, a Building Crane can make a city improvement more affordable, while the Alchemist can determine the production dice result before the normal roll. The publisher’s FAQ specifies that Alchemist still requires rolling the event die.
There is a four-card normal hand limit, so sitting on several low-impact cards can make future draws awkward. Use helpful cards while their conditions are met instead of hoarding them for a hypothetical perfect moment.
The source deck recycles spent progress cards under the matching stack, so do not assume the discard pile operates like the original CATAN development deck. Repeated effects remain a possibility, but you cannot count on drawing a particular named card on demand.
Use walls to protect flexibility, not to stop barbarians
Each city wall costs two brick and raises your hand threshold for a seven by two cards. With one wall you can hold nine cards before discarding, with two eleven, and with three thirteen. A player building toward expensive high-level improvements may benefit from the extra flexibility.
Walls are particularly useful when a player produces more commodities than they can spend each turn. Saving a large batch of coin, cloth or paper can facilitate a level-four or level-five purchase without losing half the hand to a seven.
But city walls do not protect cities from barbarians. An unprotected city with a wall can still be downgraded if the army defeats Catan and that owner is an eligible weak defender.
The best time to buy a wall is when the extra hand capacity is likely to protect useful cards. If you usually hold only four or five cards and need an activated knight urgently, spending two brick on a wall may provide little immediate benefit.
Only one wall fits under a given city. If the city is lost to barbarians, the wall is lost with it. Upgrade the economy and defence together rather than treating walls as a cheap substitute for grain and knight strength.
Shared defence creates bargaining and tactical restraint
The barbarian threat is shared, but players are still rivals. If the team has barely enough active knight strength to win the next battle, a player using a knight action to move or expel the robber may reduce the total protection available.
That decision creates negotiation opportunities. A player can explain that spending grain to keep a knight active protects several cities, while another player may reasonably ask who benefits most from the Defender of Catan point.
A player with the most active strength may secure a point after a successful defence. The lower contributors might instead prefer to invest resources elsewhere, relying on the strongest defender to carry the threat. That approach can backfire if the attack becomes too large.
Do not treat cooperation as a blanket agreement to share all resources equally. City improvements and metropolises are competitive points, so players will sometimes accept risk if it improves their personal victory chances.
As a practical rule, calculate the group’s current defence strength and each individual’s contribution after every knight activation or deactivation. That prevents disputes at the moment the ship lands and reveals whether an apparently safe position is suddenly vulnerable.
The final five points: conversion instead of expansion
Once players approach thirteen victory points, not every early-game engine investment remains valuable. An additional city improvement might lead to a metropolis and two points; a settlement might offer a direct point; or a timely progress card could change the route to victory.
Count your points from settlements, cities, metropolises, Defender of Catan rewards, Longest Road and relevant progress-card effects. Then identify what you can realistically obtain before another player finishes on their own turn.
The first player to reach thirteen on their turn wins, so a large production engine matters less if it cannot be converted to points in time. Do not spend valuable commodities on a distant future benefit while an opponent is already close to winning.
At the same time, a barbarian attack can swing the game dramatically. Losing an ordinary city removes a point and downgrades production, while losing a metropolis to a rival’s level-five improvement changes both players’ scores.
Reassess the metropolis race even late in the game. It may be better to prevent an opponent’s permanent two-point prize than to improve a track that cannot produce useful progress cards before the end.
Common strategic mistakes and how to avoid them
Ignoring the first invasion: the ship can move quickly, and a newly activated knight cannot be used for an action immediately. Recruit and activate before the danger reaches the coast.
Overinvesting in cities without defence: every city increases the barbarian army’s strength. If there is not enough active knight strength, the group can lose a city, wiping out part of the economic advantage.
Misreading commodities: one paper is not interchangeable with one grain. The three commodity types have specific improvement uses and can be traded under special rules.
Using knights as though they were the base game’s development cards: physical knights must be activated, occupy intersections and can break roads. The old Largest Army award is not used.
Confusing walls with military defence: walls protect hand size on a seven, not cities from a barbarian raid.
Treating level-four metropolises as permanent: a rival reaching level five first can claim the piece. Plan the race beyond its first milestone.
Hoarding progress cards: four is the normal limit, and effects often depend on specific timing. A hand full of cards you cannot use has low practical value.
Cities & Knights strategy FAQ
What is the best first purchase?
It depends on production and the invasion clock, but an activated basic knight is a common early priority when defence is lacking.
Which city improvement track is strongest?
No universal winner. Science smooths production, trade converts commodities, and politics enables mighty knights and its own progress cards.
Are metropolises worth chasing?
Yes when reachable, because each adds two points, but level-four control is vulnerable to a rival who reaches level five first.
How much grain should I keep?
Enough to maintain your likely knight activations before attacks while also funding normal buildings. Exact quantities depend on your supply and the ship’s position.
Do walls help against barbarians?
No. They help you hold more cards when a seven is rolled.
Can a player without cities still receive progress cards?
The publisher FAQ says losing your last city does not remove previously earned improvements or progress cards, but it prevents new improvement purchases until you rebuild.
Why compete for level five?
The first to reach it in a track secures permanent control of that track’s two-point metropolis.
Does Longest Road still matter?
Yes. It remains a scoring source, but knights on intersections can interrupt opposing continuous routes.
Evidence and scope
Reviewed November 14, 2026. The tactical principles come from CATAN’s official Cities & Knights product and tips page, its detailed FAQ, and the publisher rulebook directory.
The 2025 Cities & Knights rulebook establishes the thirteen-point target, commodity system, knight costs and the level-four/level-five metropolis distinction. These are published game mechanics, not statistical evidence that a particular development track always wins.
Where strategic value depends on game state, the article explains the relevant factors instead of inventing an optimal opening or card tier list. We have not independently tested thousands of sessions and do not claim a measured winning percentage for a specific city position.
For exact setup, turn order and battle resolution read How to Play Cities & Knights. Our expansion overview helps buyers decide whether to add it, while the CATAN expansions comparison and base CATAN strategy cover adjacent questions.
You can record campaign-free competitive games, opponents and point totals with BoardGameArchive Companion.