Brass Birmingham Loans & Income: Levels and Shortfalls
When a £30 Loan is legal, how three Income levels differ from spaces, and what happens when your income is negative.
No principal repayment; income changes each round
Quick answer: what does a Birmingham loan cost?
In Brass: Birmingham, a Loan action gives you £30 immediately and moves your Income marker three income levels backward, not three individual spaces. Place the marker on the highest space within the new lower income level.
There is no separate loan debt to repay. The cost is receiving less income—or owing more negative income—during later rounds. You may not take a loan if doing so would move your Income level below −10.
This differs from Brass: Lancashire, where loans can be taken for £10, £20 or £30 and have an additional restriction near the end of the Rail Era. This article follows the Birmingham rulebook specifically.
How to take the Loan action
A normal Birmingham turn provides actions for which you discard a card. For the Loan action, discard any one card from your hand to your discard pile. Unlike Build, the card does not need to match a city or industry.
Take £30 from the bank, then adjust the Income marker on the track backward by three Income levels. Stop at the highest position inside the resulting level as the rulebook requires.
Taking a loan spends one ordinary action. It does not directly build a mine, give extra cards or grant an immediate VP award. The cash can be used on legal later actions and required payments.
Income levels are not the same as track spaces
The Income track groups individual spaces into numbered levels. When a tile flips, its printed income advance moves the marker a number of spaces. A Loan instead pushes the marker backward three whole numbered levels.
The amount of physical movement can therefore differ depending on the marker’s current location within a level. Do not simply move the pawn three printed tick marks and announce the loan complete.
After moving to the new lower level, use the highest position in that level. This placement convention matters because the next flipped industry can advance income along the track from that precise space.
Worked example: £30 today, lower income tomorrow
Suppose your Income marker currently displays level 6. A Loan takes £30 from the bank and lowers you three Income levels, to level 3, with the marker placed on the highest space within level 3.
At the end of a normal subsequent round, you receive £3 instead of the £6 you would have received if your level had remained six. This lower recurring income is the economic cost of taking the loan.
The exact track spaces matter if a later Industry tile flips. For instance, a printed two-space income increase moves the marker two spaces forward, not necessarily two whole levels.
Can income fall below zero?
Yes. Brass: Birmingham allows a negative Income level, and your marker may move into negative values after a Loan. The Loan restriction is only that the new Income level cannot be below −10.
At the normal income step, a negative level requires you to pay that many pounds to the bank instead of collecting money. For example, Income level −2 means paying £2 at the appropriate round-end income step.
Do not confuse negative Income with owing a separately tracked loan principal. There is no £30 repayment action required after taking a Birmingham loan; the negative income payments are part of the regular income system.
When is income actually received or paid?
During End of Round, after determining the next turn order, players take income equal to their current Income level. A negative number means a payment to the bank.
The marker must be read at its current position after all industry flips and Loan actions that occurred during the round. If an opponent consumed your last coal cube and flipped your mine during their turn, the income increase can affect what you collect at the next income step.
The standard rule has one important exception: no income is collected at the end of the final round of the game. Do not add a final ordinary income payment after the Rail Era’s final round before scoring.
What if I cannot afford negative income?
If your Income level is negative and your cash cannot cover the required payment, the rules require you to raise money by removing one or more of your own Industry tiles from the board, not Link tiles.
Each removed Industry tile supplies money equal to half its printed build cost, rounded down. The tile is removed from the game. You keep any excess money obtained, but must stop removing tiles as soon as you have enough to cover the shortfall.
This is an exceptional emergency procedure. You cannot voluntarily liquidate Industry tiles for money whenever you wish; it is allowed only to pay an actual income shortfall under the printed rule.
What happens if I still cannot cover the shortfall?
After using any legal Industry-tile removals, if you still cannot pay the full negative income, you lose one Victory Point for each remaining £1 of the shortfall, if you have VP available to lose.
Example: you owe £5 in negative income but have only £1 and no industry tiles that can provide cash. Pay the £1; the remaining £4 shortfall costs four VP, as far as the available VP track permits.
The rule does not invent a negative cash balance you repay later. Follow the shortfall and VP-loss procedure when the income payment is due, rather than carrying an unrecorded debt into future rounds.
Removing tiles versus flipping industries
A tile removed to raise cash for negative income is taken off the board, not flipped. It cannot later score era-end VP there and does not receive a normal flip-income benefit.
A different industry may flip normally when its last coal, iron or beer is consumed, or when its goods are sold. Those flips advance Income and may create final points for the owner.
When deciding whether a Loan is affordable long term, account for the risk that you might have to sacrifice valuable Industries to satisfy negative income. That potential loss is more severe than the visible three-level decline alone.
The minimum −10 and maximum 30 levels
A Birmingham Loan is forbidden if the three-level decrease would take Income below −10. For example, with Income level −8, moving three levels backward would reach −11, so you cannot legally take that loan.
Income advances from flipped industries are also capped: the rulebook prevents your Income level from going above 30. A printed advance that would otherwise overshoot cannot create income level 31 or higher.
These caps affect the legal placement of the marker. They do not change the fact that a Loan grants £30 when legal, nor do they make a positive Income marker a source of immediate victory points.
Does an Income level score VP at game end?
In a normal full Brass: Birmingham game, your Income level is not directly converted into victory points at game end. Final scoring instead counts the links and flipped industry tiles in each era according to the rulebook.
Income does matter as the first tie-breaker after equal Victory Points; remaining money is the next tie-breaker. It also produces money during normal income steps, so a higher level often gives useful purchasing flexibility.
The shorter introductory Canal Era game has additional scoring rules involving Income and cash. Do not apply those introductory-only points to the ordinary two-era game.
Can you take more than one Loan?
You can take multiple Loan actions during the game as long as each is legal and the resulting Income never falls below −10. Each Loan independently grants £30 and moves Income back three levels.
A player could even use both actions of a normal turn on Loans, provided the card and Income requirements are satisfied. That would provide £60 and decrease Income a total of six levels over two separate actions.
This is not always a sensible economic choice, because subsequent negative-income payments and reduced round income can create a large cumulative burden, especially if many rounds remain.
Should loans be taken early or late?
An early Loan produces £30 of usable cash immediately, allowing more industry and link actions before rivals occupy valuable spaces. But you then receive lower income for more future rounds.
A late Loan has fewer future income steps through which its penalty can accumulate. However, there may be fewer actions remaining to convert that £30 into flipped industries or scored links. The value depends on your actual hand and network.
Unlike Lancashire, Birmingham’s normal Loan action does not have the same printed final-four-round prohibition. Always check the Birmingham board and rulebook, rather than importing a restriction from the other title.
Track money spent separately from income
Brass: Birmingham sets the next round’s player order according to how much money each player spent during the preceding round, with lower spenders acting earlier. Your character marker and spent money are tracked separately from your Income level.
Receiving £30 from a Loan is not spending £30. The money becomes part of your cash supply, and only subsequent payments for industries, networks or other costs contribute to that later turn-order calculation.
Income is also separate from cash on hand. You can have a healthy positive Income level while temporarily holding little cash, or a negative Income level while holding plenty of cash from recent Loans.
Worked shortfall: tile sale or Victory Point loss
You finish a round at Income −4 and have just £1 cash. You need another £3 to pay the bank. You own an Industry tile on the board with a printed build cost of £9, so removing it raises £4 (half of nine rounded down).
Remove the tile, add £4 and pay the required £4, leaving £1. The industry is now gone and will not score at era end. You must stop selling tiles once you have enough to cover the payment.
If you had no eligible Industry tiles at all, you would pay your £1 and lose up to three VP for the remaining £3 shortage. Neither case means the original £30 loan is later paid back as principal.
Brass Birmingham Loan FAQ
How much cash does a Loan provide? £30.
How many Income levels does it cost? Three.
Do I move three spaces? No, three levels.
Can I repay the loan principal? No, there is no normal repayment procedure.
Can Income be negative? Yes, down to the allowed limit.
What if I cannot pay negative income? Remove Industry tiles if possible, then lose VP for remaining shortage.
Can I sell a Link to pay? No.
Does Income directly score at the full game’s end? No; it can break ties.
Rules sources and more Brass Birmingham guidance
Verified against Brass: Birmingham rulebook: Loan Action, Take Income and Shortfall and Roxley’s official Brass: Birmingham resources. The rulebook distinguishes loan-level decreases from flip-space advances and explains the negative-income exception.
Related articles: How to Play Brass: Birmingham, strategy and loan timing, scoring and coal/iron markets.